How Much Harm Can The Zika Virus Really Do? | KUOW News and Information

How Much Harm Can The Zika Virus Really Do?

Feb 2, 2016
Originally published on February 4, 2016 11:08 am

How much harm can the Zika virus do?

That's the question that is bedeviling researchers in Brazil. It's not just the matter of a possible link to brain damage in babies born to mothers who contracted the virus during pregnancy. There have also been suspected cases of adult patients who suffered temporary hearing loss.

Researchers are trying to make sense of it all, and yet they lack very basic information. Even the number of cases and the degree to which it has spread are unknown.

That makes it hard to figure out the true impact of Zika. One reason that it's hard to know whether there's a link between Zika and reports of brain damage is that it's hard to know whether a pregnant woman actually had the virus.

Doctors in Brazil say the most important thing they need to have as quickly as possible is a reliable and fast way to test for the virus.

"The big difficulty right now is really to be able to test with certainty if someone had Zika or some other infection, like dengue, which is very similar," says Dr. Rafael Franza, an immunologist in the city of Recife, the epicenter of the outbreak.

Franza heads a team working with Glasgow University to develop a rapid test. At the moment, he says, the only way to determine whether you have been infected is to do a blood test within five days of the infection. The first problem: Most cases are asymptomatic, so you may not know you have Zika at all. The second problem: resources.

He says only 16 public labs in Brazil are equipped to test for the virus, which requires a molecular study of the sample. Brazil's Ministry of Health has announced it is sending out equipment so that a total of 27 labs will be able to do the blood tests.

Brazil is also making it mandatory starting next week for hospitals to report how many suspected cases of Zika they are dealing with.

This lack of testing ability affects the ability of doctors to determine how often cases of brain damage in infants are linked to Zika, says Dr. Manoel Barral. He is the director in Bahia of the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, a Brazilian medical research behemoth.

In Bahia, doctors are also focusing on what happens to adults who caught Zika.

"The initial manifestations are kind of mild, like [a] rash, but if it's severe enough to cause microcephaly and brain damage, what else can be attributed to [the virus]? We have to investigate more," he says.

Indeed, there are indications that Zika in adults can have lingering neurological effects.

"The problem may be worse than we think," says Barral.

"After Zika they started with some symptoms like vertigo or dizziness and hearing loss and tinnitus [ringing in the ears]," says Dr. Viviane Boaventura, an ear, nose and throat specialist who works with Barral. She is studying 10 patients who are suspected of having had Zika.

Up to two months after contracting the virus, Boaventura reports, the 10 patients suffered measurable and significant hearing loss as well as lightheadedness. She has been monitoring these patients since May.

The symptoms require further investigation, she says, emphasizing that these effects seem temporary and almost all of the 10 patients have recovered fully.

"We are just starting," she says. "And we don't have a lot of patients to tell you if [the damage] will be reversible or it will be permanent."

Other questions are looming. If you've had the virus once, does that make you immune? Doctors assume so but don't know for sure. Can it be sexually transmitted? There are several cases that indicate it's possible.

With doctors now focusing on the virus, the hope is there will be answers in the weeks and months to come.

Copyright 2016 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:

Health officials in Dallas are reporting a case of the Zika virus that was acquired through sexual transmission. The patient got infected from someone who had been to a country where the virus is currently circulating. This kind of transition has been reported elsewhere in the world, but this is the first case confirmed by the CDC in the U.S. from the ongoing outbreak in the Americas. In Brazil, researchers are still trying to figure out how often the Zika virus causes babies to be born with small heads and brain damage. Over half a million people are believed to have been infected with Zika in that country, but it's hard to know how far it spread. NPR's Lourdes Garcia-Navarro reports.

LOURDES GARCIA-NAVARRO, BYLINE: Doctors in Brazil say the most important thing they need to have as quickly as possible is a reliable, fast way to test for the Zika virus. Rafael Franza is an immunologist in the city of Recife.

RAFAEL FRANZA: (Speaking Portuguese).

GARCIA-NAVARRO: "The big difficulty right now," he says, "is really to be able to test with certainty if someone had Zika or some other infection like dengue, which is very similar," he says. Franza works in the city that's been at the epicenter of the Zika outbreak, and he's heading up a team that's working with Glasgow University on developing a rapid test. He says at the moment, the only way to determine if you've been infected is to do a blood test within five days of that infection. First problem - most cases are asymptomatic, so you may not know you've had Zika at all. Second problem? Resources.

FRANZA: (Speaking Portuguese).

GARCIA-NAVARRO: He says only 16 public labs are equipped to test for the virus here in Brazil, which requires a molecular study of the sample. Brazil's ministry of health has announced it's sending out equipment so that 27 labs will be able to do the blood tests in the coming weeks. This lack of quick tests is also affecting the ability of doctors to determine how often cases of brain damage in infants are linked to Zika, says Manoel Barral. He's the director in Bahia of the Brazilian medical research behemoth, the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation. Said he believes the ministry of health is being cautious but fair about the numbers.

MANOEL BARRAL: Only cases that are being detected are classified in a manner that is correct.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: He says this epidemic is causing doctors to scramble to learn about an illness that hasn't been well studied. In Bahia, they're focusing on what happens to adults who caught Zika beyond the impact on pregnant women.

BARRAL: These initial manifestations are kind of mild - I mean, like a rash. But if it's severe enough to cause microcephaly and brain damage, what else can be attributed to the adult health?

GARCIA-NAVARRO: There are indications that Zika in adults can have lingering neurological effects.

BARRAL: The problem may be worse than we think so far, this is the idea.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: Dr. Viviane Boaventura is an ears, nose and throat specialist who works with director Barral. We reached her by phone. She says she's studying 10 patients who are suspected of having had Zika.

VIVIANE BOAVENTURA: After Zika, they started with some symptoms like vertigo or dizziness or hearing loss, and also tinnitus.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: It's hard to hear, but what she's saying is for up to two months after contracting Zika, she's had 10 patients who suffer measurable and significant hearing loss and lightheadedness. They've been monitoring these patients since May. She says it requires further investigation, and she emphasizes these effects seem to have been temporary and almost all of the patients recovered fully.

BOAVENTURA: We're just starting. We don't have a lot of patients to tell you if in all of the cases, it will be reversible or permanent.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: The other questions that are looming about Zika - if you've had the virus once, does that make you immune? Doctors assume that is the case, but they don't know for sure. Lourdes Garcia-Navarro, NPR News, Rio de Janeiro. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.