Remember NAFTA? It might keep Atlantic salmon farms in Puget Sound
The Canadian owner of an Atlantic salmon farm that collapsed last summer near Anacortes vows to use the North American Free Trade Agreement to save its fish farms in Puget Sound. New Brunswick, Canada-based Cooke Aquaculture says it will pursue mandatory arbitration under NAFTA if the Washington legislature tries to phase out Atlantic salmon farming.
Both chambers in Olympia have passed bills that would phase out farming of Atlantic salmon in Washington waters. If legislators reconcile the bills’ differences, Gov. Jay Inslee is expected to sign the phase-out of Atlantic salmon farming into law.
Company vice president Joel Richardson said Cooke has been willing to compromise, even offering to raise only female fishes in order to prevent escaped Atlantic salmon from spawning and taking over wild salmon streams.
"The Senate and the House is really leaving us with very few options to continue our operations here," he said Monday night.
Richardson said the company will seek to recover the $76 million it has invested in its fish farms in Washington, as well as costs and lost profits.
"They're taking that investment away unjustly, and that deserves compensation, and there's a very real possibility that could be arbitrated under NAFTA," Richardson said.
Washington state officials estimate that 250,000 Atlantic salmon escaped Cooke’s farm near Anacortes after it collapsed in August. The company says 160,000 of the farm’s 305,000 salmon escaped.
The previous, American owners of Cooke’s eight Washington fish farms also had major structural failures and salmon escapes in the late 1990s, according to the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife:
- 1996: 107,000 fish swim free after an anchor line fails on a salmon farm
- 1997: 369,000 fish escape while a salmon farm is towed away from a toxic algae bloom
- 1999: 115,000 fish break loose from a net-pen during a strong tidal current
“Those American companies that owned the same facilities that we owned had escapes actually larger than ours, and the state did nothing about it,” Richardson said. “Nor did they introduce a ban to eliminate the industry.”
Cooke, now the only commercial producer of farmed salmon in the United States, purchased Seattle-based Icicle Seafoods and its eight Washington state salmon farms in 2016. The Canadian aquaculture giant owns Atlantic salmon farms on three continents.
Under NAFTA, governments in Canada, Mexico and the United States have to treat foreign investors as favorably (or as favourably, of course, in Canada) as they do domestic investors. Foreign investors, like Cooke in Washington state, can seek damages from governments in private, binding arbitration.
If Cooke were to successfully use NAFTA arbitration to block or be compensated for a state law, it would be a first: the United States has yet to lose such an arbitration case under NAFTA or other trade agreements.
Washington Department of Natural Resources spokesperson Carlo Davis declined to comment Monday night.
Washington Sen. Kevin Ranker of Orcas Island, who sponsored legislation to ban Atlantic salmon farms from state waters, could not be reached for comment Monday night. Nor could representatives of Puget Sound-area tribes, which strongly oppose Atlantic salmon farms.
Cooke announced its possible NAFTA strategy at 5:01 p.m. Monday, on the U.S. Presidents Day holiday, possibly echoing Washington state officials' announcement of violations at Cooke's Bainbridge Island salmon farm on Oct. 9: Canadian Thanksgiving.
John Ryan loves getting tips and documents. He can be reached at email@example.com or on the encrypted Signal or WhatsApp apps at 1-401-405-1206 (whistleblowers, never do so from a work or government device, account or location). For greatest security, use KUOW's SecureDrop portal. Snail mail is also a safe way to reach him confidentially: KUOW, 4518 University Way NE #310, Seattle, WA 98105. Don't put your return address on the outside.