Why Greece Has Been Slow To Embrace Clean Energy | KUOW News and Information

Why Greece Has Been Slow To Embrace Clean Energy

Jul 30, 2017
Originally published on September 4, 2017 7:40 am

The sea winds of Greece are legendary.

The strong, dry north Etesian winds, also known as the meltemia, blow on the Aegean Sea from May to September.

Then there are the fierce main winds, which blew mighty waves towards Odysseus in Homer's Odyssey. "Then were the knees of Odysseus loosened and his heart melted, and deeply moved he spoke to his own mighty spirit: 'Ah me, wretched that I am! What is to befall me at the last?'"

Odysseus may have seen the winds as a curse. But on the island of Tilos, they're a blessing.

In a little over a month, Tilos is set to become the first island in the Mediterranean powered solely by wind and sun.

The remote Aegean island, with a population of 400 year-round that swells to 800 in the summer, is near the coast of Turkey. The port looks like a postcard with whitewashed houses, bright-pink bougainvillea and sage-covered hills in the distance.

Mayor Maria Kamma is waiting at a cafe on the tree-lined promenade. Over beers and roasted goat, she explains that the island has scaled its tourism to be sustainable.

"We have built our tourism offerings to scale," she says. "Small inns that don't use much water, for example. Every year, we see it raining less and less here, and we don't want to waste what we don't have."

The island is also a nature reserve, with more than 650 plant varieties, a nesting ground for partridges and eagles. Kamma says the 13,000 tourists who come here annually like its sustainable vibe.

"An increasing number of tourists come here every year for this reason," she says. "So we wanted to evolve from simply a green island into a clean-energy island. We wanted to do something substantive."

She reached out to engineers at the Technological Educational Institute (TEI) of Piraeus, who designed a small solar park, wind turbine and battery storage system.

"We developed a solution tailored to the needs of the island," says Dimitris Zafirakis, a mechanical engineer at TEI Piraeus who led work on the project. "We didn't want to oversize it — so the community wouldn't feel overwhelmed. We also wanted to figure in variability on those very few days the sun doesn't shine or the wind doesn't blow. That's why we store energy in a battery, so Tilos will have energy at all time."

The $16 million project is funded largely by the European Union, with help from the Eunice Energy Group, a Greek renewable energy developer.

Standing next to the wind turbine, which workers have just finished installing, Tilos municipal advisor Stathis Kontos looks over a deep blue bay.

"That's the island of Kos in the distance," he says. "In the water below is a cable that gets us electricity from a diesel plant on the island. Greece imports diesel. We don't want to use this cable anymore."

Kontos moved here a couple of years ago because he admired that the island saw the ever-present Greek sun and wind as gifts.

"Greece can do it," he says. "We can do difficult things. We are only 400 people here, and if 400 people in a small island can do that, I think everybody in Greece can do that."

A big step for Tilos, a small step for Greece

Back in Athens, not everyone is optimistic.

"Tilos is a good example to acquaint people with the power of renewables," says Yiannis Tsipouridis, a wind-energy advocate and the former head of renewables for Greece's electricity company, the Public Power Corporation. "But it's a small island, small needs. It will just cover the local needs."

Tsipouridis says the Aegean should be a clean-energy production unit — that every island could be a Tilos, with a scaled solar-and-wind energy production unit that can also export power.

"The first wind park in Europe was installed in Greece in 1982," he says. "We started fantastically. But we have never had a long-term energy plan. We have had efforts by only a few leaders."

Renewables now supply 20 percent of the country's electricity, largely because of a push by former Prime Minister George Papandreou, a strong advocate of renewable energy. But that percentage is less than what it is in Germany — a cloudier country.

Tsipouridis is frustrated by Greece's history of dependence on lignite coal.

"We're one of the few countries that's constructing new lignite stations," he says. "Totally wrong. You have to persuade the political system that [solar and wind power] is treasure to utilize. You can't do that because we have lignite, which they think is God's gift."

'Lignite is ours'

Giorgos Adamidis is one of the people in the political system who has lobbied hard for lignite. He runs the union representing workers at the Public Power Corporation.

"I believe there is some human involvement in climate change but there's no way it's so high that it will destroy the planet," says Adamidis, who worked in coal plants. "I can't imagine that, and scientists haven't proved it, in my opinion."

The union applauded when President Donald Trump withdrew from the Paris Climate Accords. Though Adamidis says he cringes at Trump's description of climate change as a "Chinese hoax," he believes the financial interests of renewable-energy companies are pushing climate-change fears.

"So why shouldn't we push our own interests?" he says. "Lignite is ours! Lignite is our own fuel, we have to utilize it, defend it, and not shut down the plants.

Lignite coal has created thousands of jobs at mines and power plants in the northern Greek province of Western Macedonia.

"Lignite helped develop Greece after World War II," says Lefteris Ioannidis, mayor of the municipality of Kozani, the epicenter of coal country. "It was cheap, accessible fuel that helped everybody here get jobs with good salaries. And this region, all of Greece, really, got addicted to it. It's been hard to change that."

We meet at the village of Agios Dimitrios, next to one of the largest and most polluting coal-fired plants in Europe.

Workers in protective suits stand next to a conveyor belt carrying coal. Fumes pour out of smokestacks. The air is hot and heavy.

Right behind the coal plant are solar panels. "Those are private, put up by some farmers upset that the coal plant is using up so much of the area's water," Ioannidis says. "I always say coal is our past, and renewables are our future."

Unlike many here, Ioannidis never worked in coal. A member of Greece's Ecologist Greens party, he believes lignite has destroyed the environment here.

"We've moved entire villages because the land, water, air are too polluted," he says.

At a cafe run by a retired coal-miner, Ioannidis strikes up a conversation with 57-year-old Dimitris Tsavdaridis, who started working at the plant in his teens and just retired. Tsavdaridis lived in one of the evacuated villages.

"We had a lot of problems with cancer, with respiratory diseases," he says.

Tsavdaridis says he also believes burning lignite has contributed to climate change. Each year, the heat waves get more unbearable, he says. Farmland in Crete is becoming desert. A lack of rain has fueled catastrophic forest fires.

But people here need jobs. The unemployment rate in the Kozani area is 30 percent.

Ioannidis says that if people here are retrained to work in renewable energy, they will back it.

"They know Greece's future is in renewable energy," he says. "We've already approached the government about training people to build wind turbines and solar panels here."

Wind turbines and gay goats

About a third of Greece's energy production now comes from lignite. It's going down because lignite is set to run out in about 30 years. Greece is now importing diesel, transporting it to power the Aegean islands.

Nikos Mantzaris of World Wildlife Fund Greece says it costs Greek taxpayers more than $800 million a year to transport imported diesel to the islands.

"Systems such as the Tilos project can reduce electricity bills as well as protect public health," Mantzaris says. "But renewables have become a threat. As a result of pressure from the oil and lignite lobbies, Greek governments have tried to stall progress in renewables in order to leave electrical space for lignite in the mainland and oil on the islands."

This enrages Yiannis Tsipouridis, the wind power advocate.

"Really I hate myself when I say that, but I have to say it: Do you think if Greece was inhabited by Germans, God forbid, that the Aegean would have diesel stations?" he says.

Tsipouridis has tried for years to sell wind parks to islanders. He's made some inroads, but not enough to call wind energy a success in Greece.

He says many islanders are wary of wind parks — and some not just for the usual reasons, like birds dying or turbines spoiling views.

He's heard weird excuses: Wind turbines cause miscarriages, they chase away clouds so it won't rain.

And he will never forget one Greek farmer's insistence that they changed the sexual orientation of his goats.

"My goats have turned gay," Tsipouridis says, smiling and shaking his head. "He said it."

Legacy of a visionary mayor

Tilos is okay with that. If this remote island outpost is forward-thinking, much of the credit goes to a pioneering mayor named Tasos Aliferis.

He arrived here in the 1980s as a young doctor doing his required five-year rural service. He fell in love with the island and told the villagers, many of whom wanted to flee to Athens, that they lived in paradise.

Aliferis banned hunting here in 1993 and turned the sage-covered hills into a nature reserve.

In 2008, he officiated at the first gay wedding in Greece.

Stricken with cancer the next year, he helped launch this clean energy plan. As he lay dying in 2012, he told his son, Spiros Aliferis, to help carry it out.

"He told me that, whatever barrier that's in our way, we have to make it happen," says Spiros Aliferis, walking along the tree-lined promenade named after his father. "We got the entire island involved in it."

The islanders proudly sport #Proud4Tilos T-shirts. A Syrian father, among the 45 refugees that the island is housing and training for jobs, even helped clear the road for the wind turbine.

The Tilos project has already won awards from the EU, but Mayor Maria Kamma says she'd like to do more, like bring in electric cars with charging stations.

"We are a tiny island in a small country," she says. "We know that climate change is bigger than us. But we will do whatever we can to keep our paradise going a little while longer."

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

LULU GARCIA-NAVARRO, HOST:

This summer, we've been reporting on the ways people around the world are contributing to and dealing with climate change. Greece has been slow to adopt clean energy, as Joanna Kakissis explains.

(SOUNDBITE OF WIND BLOWING OVER WATER)

JOANNA KAKISSIS, BYLINE: The sound that you're hearing is the wind whipping across the Aegean Sea. The winds here are legendary. There are the seasonal winds, which the ancient Greeks called the etesiai. And then there are the main winds, which Homer described in the "Odyssey".

(SOUNDBITE OF POEM, "ODYSSEY")

KEVIN BEESLEY, BYLINE: Together the East Wind and the South Wind dashed. And the fierce-blowing West Wind and the North Wind, borne in the bright heaven, rolling before him, a mighty wave. Then were the knees of Odysseus loosened, and his heart melted. And deeply moved, he spoke to his own mighty spirit - ah me, wretched that I am. What is to befall me at the last?

KAKISSIS: Odysseus may have seen the winds as a curse. But on the island of Tilos they're a blessing. In a little over a month, Tilos, population 400, will become the first island in the Mediterranean powered solely by wind and sun.

(SOUNDBITE OF WIND BLOWING OVER WATER)

KAKISSIS: I recorded the wind on a ferry ride to this tiny island off the coast of Turkey.

(SOUNDBITE OF WIND BLOWING OVER WATER)

KAKISSIS: The port looks like it's right out of a postcard - whitewashed houses, bright fuchsia flowers, sage everywhere.

(SOUNDBITE OF CICADAS CHIRPING)

KAKISSIS: Mayor Maria Kamma is waiting at a seaside cafe. Over beers and roasted goat, she explains that much of the island is already a protected nature reserve.

MARIA KAMMA: (Through interpreter). An increasing number of tourists come here every year for this reason. So we wanted to evolve from simply a green island into a clean energy island. We wanted to do something substantive.

(SOUNDBITE OF CICADAS CHIRPING)

KAKISSIS: She reached out to engineers at the Technological Educational Institute of Piraeus, who designed a small solar park, wind turbine and a battery storage system. Stathis Kontos moved here to work on the project, financed by the European Union and a Greek renewable energy company.

STATHIS KONTOS: Greece can do it. We can do difficult things. We are only 400 people here. And if 400 people in a small island can do that, I think everybody in Greece can do that.

KAKISSIS: Back in Athens, not everyone is optimistic.

IOANNIS TSIPOURIDIS: Tilos is a good example to acquaint people with the use of renewables. But it's a small island, small needs. It will just cover the local needs.

KAKISSIS: That's Ioannis Tsipouridis, a wind energy advocate and the former head of renewables for Greece's electricity company, the Public Power Corporation.

TSIPOURIDIS: The Aegean should be a clean energy production unit.

KAKISSIS: Should be - but isn't yet. The first wind park in Europe did go up in Greece in 1982. But Greece didn't invest much in the industry, and renewables now supply only 20 percent of the country's electricity, less than in much less sunny Germany. Tsipouridis is frustrated by the continued reliance on lignite coal.

TSIPOURIDIS: We're one of the few countries that's constructing new lignite stations - totally wrong.

KAKISSIS: Wrong because he believes Greece could be making a lot of money exporting clean energy.

TSIPOURIDIS: So you have to persuade the political system that this is treasure to utilize. You can't do that because we have lignite, which they consider is also God's gift.

(CROSSTALK)

KAKISSIS: Giorgos Adamidis is one of those people in the political system who considers lignite God's gift. He runs the union representing workers at the Public Power Corporation. The union applauded when President Donald Trump withdrew from the Paris climate agreement.

GIORGOS ADAMIDIS: (Through interpreter) I believe there is some human involvement in climate change, but there's no way it's so high that it will destroy the planet. I can't imagine that, and scientists haven't proved it in my opinion.

KAKISSIS: Adamidis believes that the financial interests of renewable energy companies are pushing climate change fears.

ADAMIDIS: (Through interpreter) Lignite is our own fuel. We have to utilize it, defend it and not shut down the plants.

KAKISSIS: Lignite has created thousands of jobs at mines and power plants in northern Greece. Lefteris Ioannidis is the mayor of the city of Kozani, in a region that you would call the Greek West Virginia.

LEFTERIS IOANNIDIS: (Through interpreter) Lignite helped develop Greece after World War II. It was cheap, accessible fuel that helped everybody get jobs with good salaries. And this region, all of Greece really, got addicted to it. It's been hard to change that.

KAKISSIS: I meet Ioannidis in the village of Agios Dimitrios, next to one of the largest and most polluting coal-fired plants in Europe. Workers in protective suits shovel coal onto a conveyor belt. Fumes pour out of smokestacks. The air is hot and heavy.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Foreign language spoken).

KAKISSIS: At a cafe run by a retired coal miner, Ioannidis explains that many here do believe that burning lignite has contributed to climate change. But they need jobs. The unemployment rate here is 30 percent.

IOANNIDIS: (Through interpreter) If people here see that there's a clear plan to retrain them to work in renewable energy, they'll buy into it. They know Greece's future is in renewable energy. We've already approached the government about training people to build wind turbines and solar panels here.

KAKISSIS: About a third of Greece's energy production now comes from lignite coal, which is set to run out in about 30 years. Greece is increasingly importing diesel, transporting it to the Aegean Islands.

TSIPOURIDIS: And really, I hate myself when I say that. But I have to say - do you think that if Greece was inhabited by Germans, let's say - God forbid - that the Aegean would have diesel stations?

KAKISSIS: That's Ioannis Tsipouridis, the wind power advocate we met earlier. He says many islanders are wary of wind parks - and not just for the usual reasons, like birds dying or turbines spoiling views. He's heard some weird excuses.

TSIPOURIDIS: Like pregnant women were losing their babies, the clouds were being chased away...

KAKISSIS: And this one from a Greek farmer.

TSIPOURIDIS: My goats have turned gay. He said it.

KAKISSIS: Yes, that's right. That farmer claimed wind turbines can change the sexual orientation of goats.

(SOUNDBITE OF GOAT BLEATING)

KAKISSIS: Tiny Tilos and its goats are OK with that. If this remote island outpost is forward-thinking, much of the credit goes to a pioneering mayor named Tasos Aliferis. He turned the sage-covered hills into a nature reserve. He officiated at the first gay wedding in Greece, here, in 2008. And as he lay dying of cancer in 2012, he launched this clean energy plan. And his son teamed up with current Mayor Maria Kamma to realize it.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG)

UNIDENTIFIED ARTIST: (Singing in foreign language).

KAKISSIS: Mayor Kamma says she'd like to do even more.

KAMMA: (Through interpreter) We'd like to bring in electric cars with charging stations. We'd like our farms to grow organic produce and save water.

KAKISSIS: And she's hoping the rest of her sunny and windy country is watching.

Joanna Kakissis, NPR News, Tilos island in Greece. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.