Why Chinese Scientists Are More Worried Than Ever About Bird Flu | KUOW News and Information

Why Chinese Scientists Are More Worried Than Ever About Bird Flu

Apr 11, 2017
Originally published on April 11, 2017 7:23 am

At a research lab on top of a forested hill overlooking Hong Kong, scientists are growing viruses. They first drill tiny holes into an egg before inoculating it with avian influenza to observe how the virus behaves.

This lab at Hong Kong University is at the world's forefront of our understanding of H7N9, a deadly strain of the bird flu that has killed more people this season — 162 from September up to March 1 — than in any single season since when it was first discovered in humans four years ago. That worries lab director Guan Yi. But what disturbs him more is how fast this strain is evolving. "We're trying our best, but we still can't control this virus," says Guan. "It's too late for us to eradicate it."

Guan is one of the world's leading virologists. He has held some of the worst in his hands: H1N5, H1N1 and SARS. His work on Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome, or SARS, in 2003 led to the successful identification of its infectious source from live animal markets and helped China's government control the virus that had killed hundreds, avoiding a second outbreak.

He has now moved on to avian influenza.

Guan's office, which has a view of the lush hills and blue waters of Hong Kong Harbor, is decorated with ceramic figurines of ducks, geese and chickens. His adjacent lab is full of tissue samples of the birds — and of deceased humans — all of whom have perished from H7N9.

The fowl samples — along with live birds — arrive from a network of scientists who, each week, purchase birds at poultry markets throughout southern China. Back in December, Guan and his colleague Zhu Huachen began noticing something strange about them. "Some of the birds ... they will die within a day," says Zhu.

The birds that were quick to die of H7N9 were all chickens. This was a surprise, because chickens normally live with the virus in what's known as a low pathogenic state — they carry the virus but don't die from it and have a low capacity to spread it. Guan and his team discovered the H7N9 strain had mutated into a new form that kills chickens even more quickly.

"Ten years ago, H7N9 was less lethal," says Guan. "Now it's become deadlier in chickens. Before it barely affected chickens. Now many are dying. Our research shows it can kill all the chickens in our lab within 24 hours. If this latest mutation isn't stopped, more will die."

Guan says this is very bad news for a global poultry industry that's worth hundreds of billions of dollars, and he says China's government is already looking into vaccinating chickens. What worries Guan more, though, is that H7N9 has proved an ability to mutate quickly. There's no evidence that the virus has become more deadly in people. But already, in the rare cases when humans catch it from birds, more than a third of them die.

Currently, the virus hasn't been known to spread easily among humans, but Guan fears a future mutation could. "Based on my 20 years of studying H7N9 — the virus itself as well as how the government handles it — I'm pessimistic," says Guan, shaking his head. "I think this virus poses the greatest threat to humanity than any other in the past 100 years."

Guan's choice of 100 years is deliberate. Next year will mark the 100th anniversary of what was known as the Spanish flu, the most devastating epidemic in recorded history. As World War I drew to a close, the influenza of 1918 killed between 20 million and 50 million people, all dead from a flu that originated in birds. He says it's not a stretch to envision another global pandemic.

"Today, science is more advanced, we have vaccines and it's easy to diagnose," says Guan. "On the other hand, it now takes hours to spread new viruses all over the world."

Keiji Fukuda, former global director of the World Health Organization's Influenza Program, is also concerned. "We are now able to make vaccines and analyze things faster, but at the same time, the movement of people and animals is faster. There's a balance in those things. Some are helpful, some aren't. Everything's moving more quickly, and it's a shifting thing."

Fukuda, who now teaches at Hong Kong University's school of public health, says H7N9's ability to mutate from low pathogenic to highly pathogenic — deadly and infectious — in chickens disturbs him.

"It makes us queasy," Fukuda says. "Because it's a very visible way to see these viruses as restless. Some of these changes are dead-end, but some are not. And this genetic mutation is not. It's becoming more lethal for poultry. For people? We're not sure."

What's worse, says Guan, is that new mutations of the bird flu virus are typically discovered in China, a country with scores of small poultry farms run by farmers who aren't well-educated about the threat of bird flu and who often hide evidence of infected birds to protect their bottom line. "Farmers are scared of losing money. I know how they think — I'm from a rural part of China. And that's why I'm not optimistic about this."

Guan says there are a few encouraging signs.

Big cities like Shanghai have quickly shut down their live poultry markets when human cases are on the rise.

But that's just China.

Guan says preventing the next global pandemic will depend on how well the governments of individual countries collaborate. That, he says, is a different challenge altogether.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

Now to China, where a strain of bird flu has killed a record number of people this year. Scientists on the frontlines of this deadly strain are more worried than ever about its potential to spur a global pandemic. NPR's Rob Schmitz has this story.

ROB SCHMITZ, BYLINE: At a research lab on top of a forested hill overlooking Hong Kong, scientists are growing viruses.

(SOUNDBITE OF DRILL)

SCHMITZ: They drill tiny holes into an egg. Next, they'll inoculate it with avian influenza to observe how the virus behaves. This lab at Hong Kong University is at the world's forefront of our understanding of H7N9. It's a deadly strain of the bird flu that's killed more people this season - 162 - than when it was first discovered in humans four years ago. That worries lab director Guan Yi. But what disturbs him more is how fast this strain is evolving.

GUAN YI: (Through interpreter) We're trying our best, but we still can't control this virus. It's too late.

SCHMITZ: Guan is one of the world's leading virologists. His work on Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome, or SARS, in 2003 helped China's government control the virus that had killed hundreds, avoiding a second outbreak. He's now moved on to avian influenza.

His lab is full of tissue samples from chickens, ducks and humans, all who have died from H7N9. The samples arrived from a network of scientists who purchase birds at live poultry markets throughout southern China. Back in December, Guan and his colleague Zhu Huachen began noticing something strange.

ZHU HUACHEN: Some of the birds, if they look severely sick, then we purchase the birds. And then they would die within a day.

SCHMITZ: They were chickens infected with H7N9. That was strange because chickens normally could live with the virus in what's known as a low pathogenic state. Guan and his team discovered the H7N9 strain had now mutated into a new lethal form inside of chickens.

GUAN: (Through interpreter) Ten years ago, H7N9 was less lethal. Now it's become deadlier. Before, it barely affected chickens. Now many are dying. Our research shows it can kill all the chickens in our lab within 24 hours. If this latest mutation isn't stopped, more will die.

SCHMITZ: Which could be very bad news for the global poultry industry. What worries Guan more is H7N9 has proven an ability to mutate quickly. And in the rare cases when humans catch it, more than a third of them die. He fears a future mutation might make the virus more transmissible between humans.

GUAN: (Through interpreter) Based on my 20 years of studying H7N9, the virus itself as well as how the government handles it, I'm pessimistic. I think this virus poses the greatest threat to humanity than any other in the past 100 years.

SCHMITZ: Guan's choice of 100 years is deliberate.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED JOURNALIST: For this day, November 11, 1918, marks the end of an era of hate and bloodshed and violence.

SCHMITZ: A newsreel from a Victory Day parade after World War I allows only a brief passing reference to what was called the Spanish flu.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED JOURNALIST: Grotesque and ugly in their influenza masks, the people of San Francisco celebrate.

SCHMITZ: As the war drew to a close, the global pandemic killed between 20 and 50 million people, all dead from a flu that originated in birds.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED JOURNALIST: And so San Francisco celebrates in 1918 because the war is over, and there will never be another.

SCHMITZ: In the century since, there have been more wars. And Dr. Guan Yi says it's not a stretch to envision another global pandemic.

GUAN: (Through interpreter) Today, science is more advanced. We have vaccines. And it's easy to diagnose. On the other hand, it now takes hours to spread new viruses all over the world.

SCHMITZ: Many of these viruses are first discovered in China, a country with scores of small poultry farms run by farmers who aren't well educated about the threat of bird flu and who often hide evidence of infected birds to protect their bottom line.

GUAN: (Through interpreter) Farmers are scared of losing money. I know how they think. I'm from a rural part of China, and that's why I'm not optimistic about this.

SCHMITZ: The real test, of course, is how transmissible a future mutation of the flu is between humans. But when it comes to poultry, Guan says there are some encouraging signs. Big cities like Shanghai have quickly shut down their live poultry markets when human cases are on the rise.

But that's just China. Guan says preventing the next global pandemic will depend on how well the governments of individual countries collaborate with each other. That, he says, is a different challenge altogether. Rob Schmitz, NPR News, Hong Kong. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.