Poll: Cost Of Child Care Causes Financial Stress For Many Families | KUOW News and Information

Poll: Cost Of Child Care Causes Financial Stress For Many Families

Oct 26, 2016
Originally published on November 4, 2016 1:04 pm

Most parents have experienced sticker shock when they find out just how much it will cost to care for their infant or toddler full- or even part-time. For parents who have little choice, this can be a big financial strain.

In fact, the most common challenge parents face when looking for child care is the high cost. That's the finding of a recent poll from NPR, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

The poll surveyed a nationally representative sample of 1,120 parents or guardians of children 5 years old or younger and not yet in kindergarten, who receive regularly scheduled care at least once a week from someone other than a parent.

"Cost continues to be an issue once parents find care, with many saying the cost is a problem for their families," says Gillian SteelFisher, research scientist and deputy director of the Harvard Opinion Research Program and the poll's academic leader. "This is especially true for those who feel their financial situation is not strong."

Patricia Bauer, who lives in San Diego with her husband and two little boys, says cost is a constant challenge. Darcy, 3, and Merrick, 15 months, are in day care. Merrick is in a home care setting and Darcy in a more structured preschool. Bauer works in educational training, and her husband is a journalist. They've always considered themselves middle class, but today, barely.

"We are struggling," says Bauer, whose entire take-home pay goes just to cover the costs of day care and preschool — a whopping $2,400 each month.

After paying for groceries, gas, utilities and other expenses, Bauer says, calling the family budget stretched is a big understatement.

"We feel like we're working so hard, but any minute we could lose everything — you know, if we had some major emergency, we don't have savings," she says.

And planning for the future? Bauer would love to. But right now there's just no way.

Before children, both she and her husband contributed to their retirement funds at work. Today, that's just not possible.

Nor is it possible to contribute to college funds for the children, which is something Bauer and her husband really feel guilty about, she says.

And while she loves being Mom to two little ones, she says she and her husband are pretty much counting down the days till the boys are in public school.

"We joke that as soon as our boys are in public school, we'll be rich!"

In our poll, the vast majority of parents say there is a fee for their child care. Nearly one-third of those parents, like Bauer, say that cost creates a financial problem. And for 71 percent of them, it's a very or somewhat serious problem.

Bauer actually considered quitting her job in order to save on day care costs. But, after crunching the numbers, she decided she just couldn't afford it because, without employer-provided health insurance, she would have to pay for health insurance herself. "That's another huge bill we couldn't afford," she says.

Many families can't even consider a high-quality preschool. The poll found that 79 percent who said their household finances are not strong said they had "just a few" or "only one" option for child care. And parents with limited options were less likely than their counterparts with more options to say the quality of their child's care is "excellent" (56 percent vs. 66 percent).

The median income for families in this country is just over $55,000 a year, and the average cost of infant child care is all but out of reach for them at $10,000 a year, says Rachel Schumacher, who directs the Office of Child Care for the federal Department of Health and Human Services. "That's a sizable chunk," she says. It rivals — and even tops — the cost of one year's college tuition at many state schools.

One thing driving the high cost of child care is that it's so labor intensive, says Schumacher. While all states differ, most require a certain number of teachers or caregivers to ensure the health and safety of children.

And even though child care teachers and caregivers are paid very low wages, often at the poverty level or below, the cost still adds up.

Now, you might think if the demand for child care is high, theories of competition would prevail and the supply would grow, resulting in greater competition. That, in turn, should result in lower prices.

But this classic marketplace scenario just doesn't work when it comes to child care, Schumacher says.

When parents don't have the money in hand to pay for high-quality care, they seek out lower quality, less expensive care options, she says, which may be unlicensed or "under the table." Therefore, she says, "it's just not going to work as your typical marketplace."

The discussion about cost and quality of child care is critical these days, says Schumacher, especially since brain research shows how important the early years are.

Because the research has shown that 700 to 1,000 new neurological connections are forming every second in those first few years of life, she says, "the architecture built in the first few years is really rapid and very critical to everything that comes after."

It's a strong argument for greater government investment in child care and early education, she says — especially when you consider that in today's world, so many parents, and even grandparents, work.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

And when parents look for childcare for their children, the most common challenge they face is cost. A poll from NPR, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health finds that cost pushes parents into hard choices. NPR's Patti Neighmond reports.

PATTI NEIGHMOND, BYLINE: Patricia Bauer always considered herself middle class. She works in educational training and her husband's a journalist.

PATRICIA BAUER: We consider ourselves middle class, but struggling to stay middle class.

NEIGHMOND: Her two boys - 1 and 3 - are in daycare. Her youngest is in a home setting and her older in a more structured preschool. Bauer's entire take home pay goes to cover just those costs. And after the family pays for groceries, gas, utilities and other expenses, she says to say their budget is stretched is an understatement.

BAUER: It makes us feel like we're working so hard, but at any minute we could lose everything. You know, if we had some major emergency and we don't have savings.

NEIGHMOND: And planning for the future? Bauer would love to. But right now there's just no way.

BAUER: We don't have big retirement funds and we're not able to invest in that right now.

NEIGHMOND: Nor can they afford to contribute to college funds, a source of concern for both parents. While Bauer loves being mom to two little ones, she says she and her husband are pretty much counting down the days till the boys are in public school.

BAUER: We always joke with each other about as soon as both of our boys are in public school, we'll be rich. Because we're just paying so much in child care that for us, you know, our kids going to public school where we're not paying over $2,000 a month for full-time care, it just seems like a dream.

NEIGHMOND: In our poll, the vast majority of parents say there is a fee for child care. And nearly one-third of them, like Bauer, say the cost creates a financial problem. And for many of them it's a very serious problem. Patricia Bauer considered not paying for daycare and quitting her job to care for her kids, but after crunching numbers decided she just couldn't afford it.

BAUER: Because then I - we would have to pay for health insurance. And that would create another huge bill that we couldn't afford.

NEIGHMOND: Many families can't even consider a high-quality preschool. Rachel Schumacher directs the Office of Childcare for the federal Department of Health and Human Services.

RACHEL SCHUMACHER: When you look at what the median income is for families in this country, it's just over $55,000. But the average cost of infant child care annually is over 10,000.

NEIGHMOND: A sizable chunk that rivals and in many states tops the cost of one year's college tuition at a state school. So why does child care cost so much? It's labor intensive. While all states differ, most require a certain number of teachers or caregivers to ensure the health and safety of children. And even then, caregivers' salaries are typically low, often in the poverty range.

SCHUMACHER: We tend to really think of early childhood years as babysitting years and they're not.

NEIGHMOND: Schumacher says brain research has shown just how critical those early years are. Children learn how to express their feelings and communicate with others. And in the best of scenarios, a firm foundation is built which nurtures curiosity and the ability to learn.

SCHUMACHER: There are about 700 to 1,000 new neurological connections that are forming every second in those first three years of life. And that doesn't happen the rest of your life. The architecture that's built in the first few years is really much more rapid and very critical to everything that comes after.

NEIGHMOND: A pretty good reason why the U.S. should invest more focus on money, she says, in early childhood education. So parents can make decisions based on quality and location, not affordability.

SCHUMACHER: And that's really not the equation we want to have when we know how important those years are for our children's future and for families' peace of mind, frankly.

NEIGHMOND: Particularly since today's world is very different than it was a few decades ago. In the past, moms and even grandparents were often able to care for the children. Today, pretty much everyone has to work. Patti Neighmond, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.