Plans For Smithsonian Museum 'Bubble' May Have Burst

May 28, 2013
Originally published on May 28, 2013 7:04 am

Call it the Smithsonian's bubble problem. One of the Smithsonian museums — the Hirshhorn museum for contemporary art — came up with an ambitious new design to add more space: Why not build a giant, inflatable structure that would be big enough for people to walk around in?

But some of the Smithsonian's trustees in Washington, D.C., haven't been blown away by the bubble.

Some say the windowless Hirshhorn museum on the National Mall looks like a concrete bunker. The building is shaped like a doughnut. The translucent blue bubble would balloon out of the hole in the middle.

The architects are world-renowned. Diller Scofidio + Renfro worked on the High Line, New York City's hugely popular public park. In a TED talk, architect Liz Diller described her vision for the Hirshhorn.

"It's basically one big volume of air that just oozes out in every direction," she said. "The membrane is translucent. It's made of silicone-coated glass fiber."

The bubble's biggest supporter was Richard Koshalek, the Hirshhorn's director. He was hired by the Smithsonian five years ago, in part to shake things up with exciting new ideas. But last week, when the Board of Trustees couldn't come to an agreement on whether to continue fundraising to build the bubble, Koshalek resigned.

Richard Kurin, the Smithsonian's undersecretary for history, art and culture, isn't optimistic about the bubble's future now, even though he thinks it would have been good for the staid National Mall.

"I think it would've shown the airiness of our democracy, the flow of things, the fact that we weren't a solid rock, unmoving type of country, so I could see its symbolic appeal," he says.

Kurin says about half of the $15 million it would take to complete the project has already been raised from private sources. But he's doubtful that the Smithsonian can raise the rest. And in these days of budget cuts and sequestration, it doesn't plan to ask Congress to pay for a bubble.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

One of the Smithsonian museums, the Hirshhorn, came up with an ambitious new design. Why not build a giant, inflatable structure that would be big enough for both art and for people to walk around in.

But as NPR's Elizabeth Blair reports, some of the Smithsonian's trustees in Washington, D.C. aren't blown away by the idea.

ELIZABETH BLAIR, BYLINE: Some say the windowless Hirshhorn Museum of Contemporary Art on the National Mall looks like a concrete bunker. The building is shaped like a donut. The translucent, blue bubble would balloon out of the hole in the middle. The architects are world-renowned; Diller, Scofidio and Renfro worked on the High Line, New York City's hugely popular public park.

In a TED talk, architect Liz Diller described her vision for the Hirshhorn.

LIZ DILLER: It's basically one big volume of air that just oozes out in every direction. The membrane is translucent. It's made of silicon-coated glass.

BLAIR: The bubble's biggest supporter was Richard Koshalek, the Hirshhorn's director. He was hired by the Smithsonian five years ago, in part to shake things up with exciting new ideas. But last week, when the Board of Trustees couldn't come to an agreement on whether to continue fundraising to build the bubble, Koshalek resigned.

Richard Kurin, the Smithsonian's Undersecretary for History, Art and Culture, isn't optimistic about the bubble's future now, even though he thinks it would've been good for the staid National Mall.

RICHARD KURIN: I think it would've shown the airiness of our democracy; the flow of things, the fact that we weren't a solid, rock, unmoving type of country. So I could see its symbolic appeal.

BLAIR: Kurin says about half of the $15 million it would take to complete the project has already been raised from private sources. But he's doubtful the Smithsonian can raise the rest. And in these days of budget cuts and sequestration, they don't plan on asking Congress to pay for a bubble.

Elizabeth Blair, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.