Jared Kushner Is In The Spotlight. But Is He In the Tradition Of American Nepotism? | KUOW News and Information

Jared Kushner Is In The Spotlight. But Is He In the Tradition Of American Nepotism?

Jul 30, 2017

When presidential adviser Jared Kushner appeared last week in a closed-door meeting of the Senate Intelligence Committee, the focus was on his contacts with Russia representatives during the 2016 campaign.

Some critics say questions about Russian contacts are so serious that Kushner should lose his White House security clearance. But few are expecting he will get fired. He is, after all, married to the president's daughter.

He's also the father of three of President Trump's grandchildren.

Matthew Dallek, a professor of political management at George Washington University, says that the hiring of close relatives has a long tradition in American politics. "We've never been a pure meritocracy, or even close to one," he said.

Dallek points to three nepotism cases in the White House itself during the 20th century.

First, shortly before the country entered World War II, President Franklin D. Roosevelt created an Office of Civilian Defense. He put first lady Eleanor Roosevelt in charge of volunteer participation.

Among other initiatives, she started a dance program for children, similar to a program created in Great Britain to provide physical exercise for children in bomb shelters.

But when Mrs. Roosevelt hired a friend to run it, "it became the first major political scandal after Pearl Harbor," Dallek said. Soon, the first lady was out of the job.

That controversy did not lead Congress to pass any anti-nepotism laws,
but the next case did. In 1961, President John F. Kennedy chose his younger brother, Robert F. Kennedy, to be attorney general. Robert Kennedy was 35 years old when he was sworn into office, about 10 months younger than Jared Kushner, who took his oath at age 36.

Kennedy's appointment eventually led to an anti-nepotism law, passed in 1967.

Jessica Levinson, who teaches political law at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles, says the law targeted nepotism at federal agencies to "give the public some faith that the people who are being paid by them are the people who are best qualified for their jobs."

The third case that raised questions about nepotism occurred in 1993 when President Clinton put his wife Hillary in charge of a task force on health care. The task force plan was decisively rejected by Congress.

And now President Trump has brought on both daughter Ivanka Trump and her husband Jared Kushner as unpaid but official White House advisers.

Kushner has big assignments, including overhauling the federal bureaucracy, managing the opioid crisis and coming up with a peace settlement for the Middle East.

Earlier this year, Trump praised Kushner at a pre-inauguration party, saying: "If you can't produce peace in the Middle East, nobody can. OK?"

So while Trump is hardly the first president to turn to his family for talent,
this is a different kind of nepotism.

Eleanor Roosevelt, Robert Kennedy and Hillary Clinton all knew politics and government from the inside. But Jared and Ivanka arrived in the White House with no political experience.

"These are not people who have resumes who could otherwise be hired for these jobs," Levinson said.

Still, the Justice Department has concluded the anti-nepotism law doesn't apply to Kushner. That's because Trump, as president, can choose his own White House staff.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

LULU GARCIA-NAVARRO, HOST:

OK. Have you heard the joke about Trump's White House? Every day is take your kid to work day - boom. While that joke is actually making the rounds, it references a real legal issue which has come back into focus because of presidential adviser Jared Kushner, who appeared last week before the Senate intelligence committee. Some critics say Kushner should lose his security clearance over his alleged Russian contacts. But few expect he will lose his job since he is, after all, married to the president's daughter. NPR's Peter Overby reports.

PETER OVERBY, BYLINE: When Kushner got back to the White House after the Senate meeting, he spoke, briefly, with the press.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

JARED KUSHNER: My name is Jared Kushner. I am senior adviser to President Donald J. Trump.

OVERBY: He's also the father of three of President Trump's grandchildren. Matthew Dallek is a professor of political management at George Washington University. He says nepotism, the hiring of close relatives, has a long tradition in American politics.

MATTHEW DALLEK: I mean, look, we've never been a pure meritocracy or even close to one (laughter).

OVERBY: Dallek points to three nepotism cases in the White House itself in just the past 80 years. First, shortly before the U.S. entered World War II, President Franklin Roosevelt created an office of civilian defense. He put first lady Eleanor Roosevelt in charge of volunteer participation. One thing she started was a dance program for children, something the British had already done for children in bomb shelters.

But when Mrs. Roosevelt hired a friend to run it, Dallek says...

DALLEK: It became the first major political scandal after Pearl Harbor.

OVERBY: And soon Mrs. Roosevelt was out of a job. This didn't lead Congress to pass any anti-nepotism laws, but the next case did.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

EARL WARREN: Mr. President, at your request, I have the very great honor to administer the oath of office to the following members of your Cabinet...

OVERBY: In 1961, Chief Justice Earl Warren swore in the Cabinet of President John Kennedy, including Kennedy's younger brother.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

WARREN: ...Robert F. Kennedy, of Massachusetts, to be attorney general.

OVERBY: Robert Kennedy's appointment led to an anti-nepotism law in 1967. Jessica Levinson teaches political law at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles. She says the law targeted nepotism governmentwide.

JESSICA LEVINSON: To try and give the public some faith that the people who are being paid by them are the people who are best qualified for their jobs.

OVERBY: The third case of nepotism is from 1993. President Bill Clinton put his wife, Hillary, in charge of a task force on health care reform.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BILL CLINTON: I think that in the coming months, the American people will learn, as the people of our state did, that we have a first lady of many talents.

OVERBY: And now President Trump has brought in both daughter Ivanka Trump and her husband Jared Kushner as advisers. Kushner has big assignments, from overhauling the federal bureaucracy to finding a peace settlement in the Middle East. Trump praised him at a pre-inauguration party.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: If you can't produce peace in the Middle East, nobody can.

OVERBY: So while Trump is hardly the first president to turn to his family for talent, this is different. Eleanor Roosevelt, Robert Kennedy and Hillary Clinton all knew politics and government from the inside. Jared and Ivanka arrived in the White House with no political experience. As Jessica Levinson notes...

LEVINSON: These are not people who have resumes - who could otherwise be hired for these jobs.

OVERBY: Still, the Justice Department has concluded Kushner is not covered by the nepotism law because the president can hire anyone he wants for his own White House staff.

Peter Overby, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.