In The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, Even Calm Is Deadly | KUOW News and Information

In The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, Even Calm Is Deadly

Aug 14, 2016
Originally published on December 8, 2016 2:31 pm

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is relatively quiet right now. After several months of attacks and killings that started last October, Israeli officials say that wave of violence has tapered off.

If this trend stays on track, it could mark yet another time that intense, headline-grabbing violence has surged, then waned, in this decades-long conflict. In other words, it looks like things are returning to a period of relative calm with no war or uprising.

But a close look at those so-called calm periods over time shows the killing rarely ever stops. Here's a fact that reveals the persistence of this fight: In the 128 months from February 2005 through September 2015 — almost 11 years — only four months saw no one killed in conflict-related violence.

NPR has examined more than a decade of data detailing Israeli fatalities — tracked by Israel's Foreign Ministry and its internal intelligence agency, the Shin Bet — and Palestinian fatalities tallied by OCHA, a United Nations agency charged with monitoring the conflict.

Those numbers represent a dynamic that keeps the conflict going — sometimes blowing up into spikes of violence that get much more attention internationally. There are calls for revenge and, perhaps as important in driving the conflict, a degree of acceptance of killings as simply part of life.

The murder of Israeli Eli Wasserman is typical of a death during relative calm. It's the kind of killing that people outside the region don't often hear about.

Wasserman worked as a security guard at an Israeli industrial zone in the West Bank. On April 25, 2008, a Palestinian gunman killed the father of two as he started his shift.

It was his wife, Chaya Wasserman's, 52nd birthday. She remembers going to bed alone that night.

"I was kind of crazed, and started crying and screaming, 'What kind of present did you give me for my birthday?'" she recalls.

To identify periods of relative calm, we began with Feb. 8, 2005. That's when, at a summit in Sharm el-Sheik, Egypt, then-Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas (who is still in office) mutually pledged to stop violence after several years of the bloody second intifada, or uprising, against Israel.

The violence did not end as pledged. There has been, however, no uprising on the scale of an intifada, and there have been long periods of relative calm between three wars since then.

Filtering out those military operations — which took place in 2008-2009, 2012 and 2014 — we stopped counting at the end of September 2015, right before the most recent wave of violence began in October.

Excluding wars, from early 2005 through September 2015, Israeli figures show Palestinians killed about 175 Israelis and a dozen non-Israelis, including U.S. visitors and Asian laborers.

Israelis killed 2,217 Palestinians during the same period, according to U.N. figures.

Palestinian teenager Laith al-Khaldi was one of them. As with Wasserman, his death shows how violence can flare even during times of relative calm.

Last July, an Israeli soldier shot Khaldi after he had been throwing rocks at a military post. Although it was a relatively calm period, almost two dozen Palestinians and three Israelis had already been killed in separate incidents in a range of confrontations during the first half of the year.

The night before Khaldi went out throwing rocks, Israeli settlers had set fire to a Palestinian home in the West Bank village, killing a baby immediately, badly burning another child and fatally wounding both parents. Khaldi's mother, Samira, says this outraged her son.

"He told us, 'Mama, why did they burn the whole family?' And he put the picture of the baby on his profile on Facebook. And he write over it, 'God can help us,' " she says.

A Palestinian autopsy found the bullet went the teen's back and out his stomach.

The Israeli military says Palestinians threw firebombs as well as rocks.

Six Palestinians, including Khaldi and the baby burned in the fire, died due to the ongoing conflict between the two sides during July 2015, the month Khaldi was shot. No Israelis were killed that month.

This is a tiny fraction of the number killed one year before, in July 2014, when Israel was at war with Hamas, the militant Islamist group that runs the Gaza Strip. In that month alone, 74 Israelis were killed, according to the Israeli government, and approximately 2,250 Palestinians were killed, according to the U.N.

Violence does drop significantly outside extreme periods of war or uprising. But it does not stop.

On both sides, the numbers add up to painful personal losses and leave deep scars. For every death, on either side, there is media coverage. Funerals are often attended not only by loved ones, but also by strangers offering sympathy and solidarity.

Israelis might mark the spot of an attack with a commemorative plaque or stone. Palestinians frequently plaster the area with posters of those killed, who they call "martyrs."

Palestinian political scientist Mohammed Dajani says the never-ending violence carries an element of revenge that keeps the conflict going.

"It is this feeling of hatred for the other. This feeling of enmity for the other. From time to time, it will spill over and destroy lives and property," Dajani says.

Dajani, who has taught Palestinian students about the Holocaust, blames politicians, including the top leaders on both sides, for exploiting those losses, promoting fear and more violence.

But it's a complex fear, says Israeli political psychologist Gilad Hirschberger. He researches the impact the fear of death has on group identity and politics.

Repeated exposure to killing makes people constantly aware of their own mortality, Hirschberger says. So they seek survival through association with something that seems larger than an individual — that is, their collective groups. These are often based on religious, cultural or national identity.

That means differences with other groups take on enormous importance, Hirschberger says. Behind fights for territory and security in this conflict, there is a constant, fundamental fear: Will my people survive?

"It's no longer a clash between two parties disagree[ing] over concrete issues," Hirschberger says. "There's something very deep going on here."

For Jews, this harks back to the Holocaust, and centuries before. For Palestinians, it rationalizes collective resistance to Israel's military occupation and control.

American political scientist Dov Waxman of Northeastern University has found that regular violence leads people to doubt the situation will ever change.

"They see it as almost an inevitable feature of life," Waxman says. "So that saps the political will, if you like, to try to change the situation."

His research has focused on Israelis. But many Palestinians also don't expect the situation will change. In addition to those killed on both sides during lulls in large-scale violence, tens of thousands of others are exposed to incidents that physically injure or traumatize them.

"We see trauma and loss like a stone thrown into water," says Sigal Haimov, co-founder of an Israeli victims' help organization. "There are the ripple effects, and they affect every part of society."

A year after an Israeli soldier killed her son, Laith, Samira Khaldi feels no happiness.

Israeli Chaya Wasserman, whose husband was killed by a Palestinian gunman, has turned to laughter therapy as one way to cope with her grief.

Neither woman sees losing her husband or son as routine. But both assume the killing will continue.

Copyright 2016 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

The Israeli-Palestinian stalemate is known for both short, hot wars and long, violent periods of uprising. Over the last decade, there have also been significant periods of calm, at least by Israeli standards. But even in these so-called quiet times, the low-level violence continues. One reason is revenge. But that is not the only reason, as NPR's Emily Harris reports.

EMILY HARRIS, BYLINE: Israeli Chaya Wasserman can't forget the date her husband was killed, April 25.

CHAYA WASSERMAN: It was my birthday.

HARRIS: Her 52nd birthday. This was 2008, a time of relative calm in the conflict. The second Palestinian uprising had long faded. Israel was not fighting a war with Hamas.

WASSERMAN: My husband asked me if it's OK to celebrate in a restaurant.

HARRIS: She liked that idea. The celebration was planned for the evening. But early that morning, news broke of a terror attack. Immediately, Wasserman called her husband.

WASSERMAN: And he didn't answer me. And we had an agreement that if I call him, he must answer me. And when he didn't answer me, I understand that he is not alive.

HARRIS: She was right. Eli Wasserman worked security at an Israeli industrial zone in the West Bank. A Palestinian gunman fatally shot him as he started his shift, early on his wife's birthday. Let's take a look at another death. An Israeli soldier killed a Palestinian teenager who'd been throwing rocks at a military post. This was July 2015 - again, a period of relative calm. But the night before, Israeli settlers had set fire to a Palestinian home, killing a baby and his parents and badly burning another child. This outraged 15-year-old Palestinian Laith Khaldi, says his mother Samira.

SAMIRA KHALDI: Laith was very much angry in the morning. And he told us - Mama, why did they burn the whole family? And he put the picture of the baby on his profile on Facebook. And he write over it, God can help us, (speaking Arabic) in Arabic.

HARRIS: Later, Laith went with friends to an Israeli military post, a lone concrete tower. They threw rocks at it and ran, Laith's mother says.

KHALDI: He was running away when they killed him. He was shooted (ph) in his back.

HARRIS: A Palestinian autopsy found the bullet went in Laith's back and out his stomach. The Israeli military says Palestinians threw fire bombs as well as rocks. To tally the deaths in these so-called quiet times, NPR got numbers of Israelis killed from the Israeli Foreign Ministry and numbers of Palestinians killed from the United Nations.

We looked at over a decade in Israel and the occupied territories, filtering out times of war and uprising. Minus all those hot periods, the death toll does drop. Still, during the generally quiet periods between early 2005 to the end of September 2015, Palestinians killed about 200 people in attacks on Israelis. That includes a dozen non-Israeli visitors or laborers. Israelis killed about 2,200 Palestinians over the same time. Another way to look at it - in a little over 10 years, there were only four months in which no one on either side died due to the conflict.

MOHAMMED DAJANI: I see it like somebody sitting next to a volcano.

HARRIS: Palestinian political scientist Mohammed Dajani says anger rumbles and will periodically erupt as long as fundamental Israeli-Palestinian problems are not solved. Ongoing killings, he says, perpetuate the feelings driving the conflict.

DAJANI: It is this feeling of hatred for the other and this feeling of enmity for the other. And from time to time, it will spill over and destroy lives and property.

HARRIS: Dajani blames politicians for exploiting those losses, adding more fuel to the fight.

DAJANI: They're trying to feed fear of the other and feeling of revenge from the other.

HARRIS: But it's not just revenge, says Israeli political psychologist Gilad Hirschberger, It's also fear.

GILAD HIRSCHBERGER: I specialize in fear of death and existential concerns and how they affect political attitudes.

HARRIS: Repeated exposure to killing reminds people, you'll die. So a constant trickle of fatal violence, Hershberger says, makes people seek survival in numbers. They glom into groups based on religious, cultural or national identity, something that will continue even when individuals die. And when that group holds such a significant role, Hirschberger says, differences with other groups take on an enormous importance.

HIRSCHBERGER: It's no longer a clash between two parties that disagree over concrete issues. There's something very deep going on here that needs to be acknowledged.

HARRIS: Behind fights for security and territory in this conflict, it's the depth of existence - will my people survive? For Jews, this harkens to the Holocaust and centuries before. For Palestinians, it rationalizes collective resistance to Israel's military occupation and control. So there's revenge. There's the heightened importance of the group. A third way persistent death perpetuates the conflict is the routine of it. American political scientist Dov Waxman of Northeastern University has studied the effects of violence on the daily life of Israelis.

DOV WAXMAN: They essentially come to accept that, to some extent. And rather than think of it as something that they can change through some sort of political solution, instead they see it as almost an inevitable feature of life. And so that saps the political will, if you like, to try to change the situation.

HARRIS: He's talking about Israelis. Many Palestinians also don't think things will change. These are the big, societal impacts of persistent violence. You see the same dynamics play out in individual lives. A year after an Israeli soldier killed her son Laith, Samira Khaldi feels no happiness. But at least, she says, Laith stood up with other Palestinians to protest unjustified deaths.

KHALDI: When they burned the whole family alive at night, my son say no.

HARRIS: Israeli Chaya Wasserman, whose husband was killed by a Palestinian gunman, says different relatives have used his death to back up their different political views. She has focused on how to cope. Eight years on, she's tried many therapeutic techniques, including laughter.

WASSERMAN: (Laughter)

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Foreign language spoken).

HARRIS: Neither woman sees the loss of a person she loved as routine, even though they both assume the killing will continue. Emily Harris, NPR News, Jerusalem. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.