An Evangelical Leader's Changing Views On Gun Ownership | KUOW News and Information

An Evangelical Leader's Changing Views On Gun Ownership

Oct 10, 2015
Originally published on October 13, 2015 2:12 pm

As the debate over gun ownership and gun control is renewed following the shooting deaths of nine people, including the gunman, at an Oregon community college earlier this month, there's the voice of an evangelical leader whose views might be different from what some would expect.

The Rev. Rob Schenck, president of Faith and Action, is an anti-abortion activist who believes gun ownership and the use of guns is a decision best decided by community leaders, and not the government.

Schenck is the subject of a soon-to-be-released documentary, The Armor of Light, which focuses on his changing stance on gun ownership. Those views were affected by the 2013 shooting at the D.C. Navy Yard, according to The Washington Post:

"For years, Rev. Rob Schenck led nonviolent protests as an anti-abortion activist, focusing on abortion as the primary 'sanctity of human life' issue.

"But everything changed after the 2013 D.C. Navy Yard shooting that left 13 people dead. A new documentary called "The Armor of Light" tracks Schenck as he decided that one cannot be both 'pro-life and also 'pro-guns.'

" 'I'll be very candid, I haven't felt that it's our issue, until we end up kneeling in prayer, outside the Navy Yard gates in my neighborhood where my apartment building was in lockdown,' he says in the film that will be released on Oct. 30. 'So suddenly it goes from theoretical to very realistic.' "

Schenck spoke with NPR's Scott Simon about his views and how they coalesce with his anti-abortion stance.

"When you talk about aiming a weapon at another human being, no matter what the circumstances are, that's a question of paramount moral and ethical dimensions, so it's something that we should take very seriously, and I don't know that a lot of us are," he says.


Interview Highlights

On his calls for gun control on a personal level rather than a legal level

Ultimately, we'll all make the decision what we will do, whether we'll own a lethal weapon and use it or not. We've had a long discussion in this country — decades-long — on gun control, that is government gun control. For me, this is a question of self-control regardless of what the law may allow me to do. I appeal to a higher law. ... I've said publicly, that in our respecting of the Second Amendment, we have to be very careful we don't break the second commandment, which is the commandment against idolatry. We can set up our own idolatry when we declare ourselves the arbiters of right and wrong, and especially, of the value of a human life.

On how his views on guns relate to his views on abortion

I've been a pro-life advocate for 30 years. I see life as having value from the moment of conception, but there's a whole lot of life after conception. It's a pro-life question, and it's a deeply moral question, and it's, even for me, it's a theological question.

On whether or not he owns a gun and why

I do not ... on principle; I've made the decision not to own a weapon. There's a lot of reasons for that. One is, I think it does create an ethical crisis for a Christian. Secondly, I don't necessarily trust myself, and maybe more of us would be better off to question what we will do in the heat of anger, fear, or God forbid, depression. My own family has a history of gun suicide due to depression. I know depression runs in families, and I don't want to take that risk.

On how he responds to people who own guns for self-defense

I understand that impulse, and I respect it. I don't impugn people's motives on that. I think an awful lot of those people are sincere, and that's a noble inclination that we have. Now whether the handgun — a lethal weapon — is the best way to manage that security for yourself and your family is another question. Sometimes, a handgun can be a shortcut in the equation.

On whether religious and ethical leaders can come to an agreement on gun ownership that politicians have missed

Yes, I do. First of all, I don't want to sound too cynical, but I think politicians are, on the whole, eminently disqualified from really giving us good guidance on this question ... they're in the business of politics. That means winning elections. They're going to do what's in their best electoral interests on the question.

I hope that religious leaders are, for the most part, in a pursuit of the truth. So I've decided I'm going to shift to where my people are most comfortable, and that's the law of the heart, and of the mind, and of the conscious. And after that, I think we can probably get to some consensus on policy and legislation.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

The debate over guns after a shooting may seem to sound like the same old arguments. The Rev. Rob Schenck might be a different voice. He's an evangelical leader, an anti-abortion activist who is president of Faith in Action, a Christian outreach organization. And he's turned his attention to guns. He joins us in our studios. Rev. Schenck, thanks very much for being with us.

ROB SCHENCK: My pleasure.

SIMON: I don't want to characterize your views. I wouldn't call them on gun policy but something else.

SCHENCK: Yeah, for me, the whole question of gun use, ownership, for defensive purposes - and I make a distinction with that. I think when you're talking about hunting and sportsmanship, you have a different discussion. But, for me, when you talk about aiming a weapon at another human being, no matter what the circumstances are, that's a question of paramount moral and ethical dimensions. So it's something we should take very seriously, and I don't know that a lot of us are.

SIMON: So you're not necessarily calling for gun control at the legal level, but in a funny way, personal gun control.

SCHENCK: Well, yeah. I don't think of it so much as funny because, ultimately, we'll all make the decision what we will do, whether we'll own a lethal weapon and use it or not. You know, we've had a long discussion in this country - decades long now - on gun control - that is, government gun control. For me, this is a question of self-control, regardless of what the law may allow me to do, I appeal to a higher law.

And I've said publicly that in our respecting of the Second Amendment, we have to be very careful we don't break the second commandment, which is the commandment against idolatry. And we can set up our own idolatry when we declare ourselves the arbiters of right and wrong and especially of the value of a human life.

SIMON: Do you see your views on guns as being consistent with your pro-life views as well?

SCHENCK: Most certainly, I've been a pro-life advocate for 30 years. I see life as having value from the moment of conception. But there's a whole lot of life after conception. It's a pro-life question, and it's a deeply moral question, and it's even, for me, a theological question.

SIMON: Forgive me if this a personal question, but you kind of opened the door. Do you own a gun?

SCHENCK: I do not.

SIMON: On principle, or...

SCHENCK: On principle. I've made the decision not to own a weapon. There's a lot of reasons for that. One is I think it does create an ethical crisis for a Christian. Secondly, I don't necessarily trust myself. And maybe, more or less, would be better off to question what we will do in the heat of anger, fear or, God forbid, depression. My own family has a history of gun suicide due to depression. I know depression runs in families. I don't want to take that risk.

SIMON: And what might you say, and probably not a hypothetical, I bet you've had this question from people who say, look, I think - I feel the need to own a gun for the self-defense of me and my family. And I think, more or less, I ought to be able to walk in some place and walk out with a gun.

SCHENCK: Sure. And I understand that impulse, and I respect it. I don't impugn people's motives on that. I think an awful lot of those people are sincere and that that's a noble inclination that we have. Now whether the handgun, a lethal weapon, is the best way to manage that security for yourself and your family is another question because sometimes a handgun can be a shortcut in the equation.

SIMON: Do you think it's possible that religious leaders and ethical leaders might be able to reach some kind of breakthrough with each other - I don't even want to broach the word compromise - that political leaders have missed?

SCHENCK: Yes, I do. First of all, I don't want to sound too cynical, but I think politicians are, on the whole, imminently disqualified from really giving us good guidance on this question because, of course, they're in the business of politics. That means winning elections. They're going to do what's in their best electoral interests on the question.

I hope that religious leaders are, for the most part, in a pursuit of the truth. So I've decided I'm going to shift to where my people are most comfortable. And that's the law of the heart and of the mind and of the conscience. And after that, I think we can probably get to some consensus on policy and legislation.

SIMON: The Rev. Rob Schenck, president of Faith in Action. Thanks so much for being with us.

SCHENCK: Thank you. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.